Amtrak warns MTA as Metro-North push faces new obstacles

Amtrak says any early Metro-North service into Penn Station hinges on trimming LIRR capacity, and that frayed relations with the MTA already complicate planning and long-term coordination.

This is reported by the railway transport news portal Railway Supply.

Amtrak concerns over culture, deadlines and scarce capacity

Frankly, the national passenger railroad talks about a mix of operational friction and bruised egos with the MTA. It says a “toxic work culture” has formed around Penn Station Access, and that public criticism slows coordination.

Don’t miss…EURO9000 Expands Its Role in Europe’s Zero-Emission Freight Market

To be fair, the MTA offers a very different story. The authority says the railroad delivered only seven of the 48 promised weekend outages, and that this shortfall boxed contractors into a narrower, slower work program.

However, project managers on the railroad side push back hard. They point to the MTA and its Halmar–RailWorks joint venture, saying crews were not ready to use outages for roughly seven months after notice to proceed. Amtrak has defended its record in a public statement. 

Still, schedule anxiety is growing on all sides; as one planner put it, “we can see the cliff coming.” In real terms, every lost weekend now forces sharper trade-offs later in the program.

For many commuters in the East Bronx, the argument feels distant but the stakes are concrete. New Metro-North stops, outlined in the Penn Station Access plan, could cut journeys by up to 50 minutes and bring rail service within about a mile of 500,000 residents. 

Amtrak conditions for early Metro-North access to Penn

In practice, the railroad says 2027 access for Metro-North requires the MTA to cut Long Island Rail Road trains into Penn Station.

It cites the Hell Gate Line framework and the 2019 operating agreement with the MTA, which together protect NJ Transit paths and Amtrak slots. 

Meanwhile, the MTA rejects those conditions. Construction chief Jamie Torres-Springer says Bronx riders have waited long enough and insists LIRR schedules will not shrink, while complaining that none of the agency’s acceleration ideas were accepted.

Penn Station already runs close to its workable limit in the peaks, so capacity is not an abstract concern. Add more trains without cuts elsewhere, planners warn, and delays will spread across commuter and intercity services.

Still, if the project reaches its 2030 finish line, the region gains a lot. Metro-North riders would have a second Manhattan terminal, more redundancy, shorter trips, and, really, a network that copes better when something fails.

News on railway transport, industry, and railway technologies from Railway Supply that you might have missed: